The Minutes

On the record about

immigration

10 people · 64 quotes · 22 Jun 2024 to 25 Aug 2026

Who is on this subjectordered by the date of their first quote here

6 of 10 lanes rest on fewer than 5 quotes and are marked thin. Offsets are days from the middle first-quote date, 9 Apr 2025 — a date, and nothing else. It is not a claim about who reached a view first.

Add someone to immigration

This files a request; it does not add anyone. Names are added by hand. Someone accepted joins as watching — the connectors start looking for them, and a lane appears here only once there are quotes. A name on its own draws nothing.

The chronologysourced and dated, oldest first

    1. Bill Gurley

      Gurley reports Trump proposed at Business Roundtable solving how to get companies more talented workers.

      “They said it was the first time they ever heard him say, and I gotta solve the problem for everybody in this room, how I get you more talented workers.”

      22 Jun 2024 · BG2 Pod · 1:01:01 · source · permalink
    2. Bill Gurley

      Gurley reports Trump proposed automatic green cards for anyone completing a four-year US degree.

      “And he proposed something apparently at the roundtable. He said, anybody who comes here for a four year education completes their degree in The United States, we're gonna give them a green card.”

      22 Jun 2024 · BG2 Pod · 1:01:08 · source · permalink
    3. Brad Gerstner

      Gerstner links job loss fears from AI to anti-immigration sentiment as predictable response.

      “You're a driver, you lose your job to autonomous driving. You know, go through the list, and we're gonna see a lot of this. Right?”

      1 Oct 2024 · Summit · 28:59 · source · permalink
    1. Howard Lutnick

      Lutnick proposes selling 400,000 green cards at $5 million each would generate $2 trillion and eliminate the deficit.

      “Do realize if we sold those 400,000 a year for 5,000,000 each? You know, that's $2,000,000,000,000 every time. 2,000,000,000,000. We'd have no budget deficit. We could lower taxes on America.”

      12 Mar 2025 · CBS Evening News · 27:12 · source · permalink
    2. Howard Lutnick

      Lutnick proposes selling 400,000 green cards at $5 million each to generate $2 trillion and eliminate deficit.

      “Do realize if we sold those 400,000 a year for 5,000,000 each? You know, that's $2,000,000,000,000 every time. 2,000,000,000,000. We'd have no budget deficit.”

      12 Mar 2025 · CBS Evening News · 27:12 · source · permalink
    3. Howard Lutnick

      Lutnick announces gold card program launching in two weeks with Elon building the software.

      “About two weeks from today, it goes out. Okay. Elon's building me the software right now. Yeah. Right. And then out it goes.”

      20 Mar 2025 · All-In Podcast · 1:11:17 · source · permalink
    4. Marc Rowan

      Rowan argues the U.S. cannot be a low-cost manufacturing center without massive immigration.

      “To the extent we do not want massive amounts of immigration, we are not going to be the low cost manufacturing center for low value goods.”

      9 Apr 2025 · CNBC Television · 2:40 · source · permalink
    5. Marc Rowan

      Rowan says labor availability is a bigger concern than capital availability in the U.S.

      “Some days I wake up and worry about capital. Most days I wake up and worry about where will we get all the people to do this.”

      5 May 2025 · Bloomberg Podcasts · 2:27 · source · permalink
    6. Bill Gurley

      Gurley notes 50% of AI researchers are Chinese-origin and China now leads in AI patents, questioning immigration restrictions.

      “some people say 50% of AI researchers are of Chinese origin. And I believe now the patent count in AI coming out of China is larger than The US.”

      5 Jun 2025 · BG2 Pod · 29:46 · source · permalink
    7. Brad Gerstner

      Gerstner cites study showing 40-50% of top US AI researchers are Chinese.

      “I saw a study that suggested that 40 to 50% of the AI researchers in The United States, our best researchers are Chinese.”

      5 Jun 2025 · BG2 Pod · 32:49 · source · permalink
    8. David Sacks

      Sacks says two million more American-born workers have jobs in 2025 while foreign-born workers lost a million.

      “Around 2,000,000 more American born workers have jobs in 2025 so far. And I think meanwhile, about a million foreign born workers roughly have lost jobs.”

      7 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 55:03 · source · permalink
    9. David Sacks

      Sacks argues the $100,000 H-1B fee will redirect applications from low-end IT jobs to high-skilled positions with actual American shortages.

      “And I think by putting this $100,000 fee on it, you encourage the applications to go to the actual higher skilled, higher paid jobs where there's actually a shortage of Americans.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 4:36 · source · permalink
    10. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya says H-1B visas have reached 10 times the intended 85,000 annual cap in recent years.

      “But here is the data. And so what you see is that in many years, the last several, it's been upwards of 10 times that number.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 7:56 · source · permalink
    11. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya cites data showing H-1B average salary is slightly under $120,000, disputing highly skilled worker narrative.

      “It's not really that case. And so I think the average salary, I just wanna get this exactly right, it's slightly under a $120,000.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 9:02 · source · permalink
    12. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya says masters and PhD graduates get OPT visas for multiple years to find jobs.

      “They are off the charts smart. But because they did a master's or a PhD, they come with a couple of years, and you can oftentimes extend that.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 11:30 · source · permalink
    13. David Friedberg

      Friedberg proposes two separate programs for highly skilled workers, citing Operation Paperclip which recruited 1,600 German scientists between 1945-1959.

      “Well, I think there should be two separate programs for what we could call highly skilled workers.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 14:00 · source · permalink
    14. David Friedberg

      Friedberg reports Florida farmers pay $5-10 over minimum wage for H-2A workers but can't attract Americans despite government subsidies.

      “And by the way, these farmers and these farm businesses are being heavily subsidized by the government.”

      27 Sep 2025 · All-In Podcast · 17:25 · source · permalink
    15. David Sacks

      Sacks cites historical precedent of JFK sending 30,000 troops to Ole Miss to justify Trump's National Guard deployment.

      “For example, when James Meredith was barred from attending Ole Miss, University of Mississippi, JFK sent in 30,000 federal troops to bust open the doors of Ole Miss.”

      10 Oct 2025 · All-In Podcast · 18:18 · source · permalink
    16. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya explains H-1B abuse where large companies apply for 300,000 visas at once, overwhelming smaller applicants.

      “What he described is that when the application window opens for what is a very small number of h one b's, a company that has, you know, call it 300,000 employees abroad will apply on behalf of all 300,000 because they're all roughly the same kind of employee. Whoever gets it gets to come over.”

      14 Nov 2025 · All-In Podcast · 37:52 · source · permalink
    17. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya describes his immigrant compact as absorbing American values, constitution knowledge, and cultural heritage celebration.

      “I want to know and be able to talk to you about the constitution of this country. I want to be able to celebrate the cultural heritage of this country.”

      13 Dec 2025 · All-In Podcast · 43:23 · source · permalink
    18. Marc Rowan

      Rowan says immigration reform and tariffs are fractionalizing labor and goods flows in inflationary ways.

      “We are, for maybe good and valid reasons, fractionalizing our labor supply through immigration reform. We're fractionalizing our flow of goods through the other tariff and other measures.”

      21 Dec 2025 · Yahoo Finance · 0:31 · source · permalink
    1. David Sacks

      Sacks says over 55% want all illegal aliens deported, 90% want criminals removed, and murders dropped 21% last year.

      “Over 55% of the American people say they want all illegal aliens deported, and over 90% want criminal aliens removed.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 12:52 · source · permalink
    2. David Sacks

      Sacks emphasizes ICE has warrants for specific named individuals, rejecting Gestapo comparisons.

      “They have warrants to arrest known criminal aliens despite this rhetoric of them being like the Gestapo. They are going after specific named individuals for whom they have warrants to arrest.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 14:11 · source · permalink
    3. David Sacks

      Sacks says blue states expected to lose nine House seats and electoral votes due to citizen migration.

      “And as a result of that, blue states are expected to lose nine house seats and electoral votes because of the changing population numbers.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 17:32 · source · permalink
    4. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya argues that the majority clearly wanted both borders shut with structured immigration path.

      “Everybody wanted the southern border shut and the northern border shut and a structured path to deal with illegal immigration.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 19:21 · source · permalink
    5. Chamath Palihapitiya

      Palihapitiya notes Tom Homan was awarded a medal by Obama for managing deportations.

      “The fact that Tom Homan is going there is a really good thing. He was the same person that was awarded a medal by Obama for how he managed Obama's deportation process.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 20:27 · source · permalink
    6. David Friedberg

      Friedberg says removing longtime taxpaying immigrants without a path to citizenship risks civil war.

      “I don't know how you're gonna do it. I don't know how you're gonna do it without inciting a civil war.”

      30 Jan 2026 · All-In Podcast · 29:18 · source · permalink
    7. David Sacks

      Sacks claims Mamdani won NYC mayoral election due to mass migrant vote combined with downwardly mobile progressives.

      “It was the mass migrant vote in New York that swung it to Mam Donnie. It's not exclusively the DSA base.”

      26 Jun 2026 · All-In Podcast · 11:31 · source · permalink
    8. JD Vance

      Vance claims Tim Walz pardoned a convicted child rapist to prevent his deportation from the United States.

      “Do remember Tim Waltz? Caught wind. And you know what he did? He pardoned the guy. He pardoned a literal child rapist to prevent him from being deported out of The United States Of America.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:55 · source · permalink
    9. JD Vance

      Vance quotes Walz questioning deportation value and responds it makes Minnesota safer for children.

      “Walt's asked the country what good it accomplished. Did that make us any safer? That is a direct quote from the Democrat governor of Minnesota.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 3:21 · source · permalink
    10. JD Vance

      Vance argues Democrats prioritize child predators, fraudsters, and foreign gang members over American taxpayers.

      “Whether it's child predators, Somali fraudsters, foreign gang members, or even visa fraudsters who are working to undercut American wages and steal from American taxpayers, the Democrats know who they stand for.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 3:55 · source · permalink
    11. JD Vance

      Vance says manufacturing wages rose 4.2 percent after falling under Biden, with higher gains in sectors with reduced illegal immigration.

      “manufacturing workers wages actually went up 4.2% where they went down under the Biden administration, and frankly, they've been higher in the industries where you've seen that decline in illegal immigration into our country like construction and commercial trucking.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 1:28 · source · permalink
    12. JD Vance

      Vance claims an incoming Democratic congresswoman wants to abolish prisons, police, and borders.

      “One incoming democrat congresswoman wants to abolish prisons, she wants to abolish police, and she wants to abolish the borders.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:20 · source · permalink
    13. JD Vance

      Vance claims closing the border required only a new president, not new legislation.

      “But as we've learned over the past eighteen months, it didn't require a new law to close down that border. It just required a new US president.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:00 · source · permalink
    14. JD Vance

      Vance says the administration told corporations to train and hire Americans before seeking foreign workers.

      “And what we did is we told American corporations that if you wanted new workers, you gotta start by training and hiring your own countrymen.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:17 · source · permalink
    15. JD Vance

      Vance claims America saw net migration outflow for the first time in his lifetime.

      “And so for the first time in my life, America saw net migration out of the country as we sent millions of illegal immigrants back home.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:42 · source · permalink
    16. JD Vance

      Vance claims all net job growth in the past eighteen months went to native-born Americans, reversing a four-year trend.

      “Do you know that all net job growth over the past eighteen months went to native born Americans, reversing a trend for four years where it all went to other people?”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 3:04 · source · permalink
    17. JD Vance

      Vance quotes Wall Street Journal editorial writer linking free trade and capital movement to free movement of labor.

      “He said someone who believes, this is a quote, in the free trade and free movements of capital, they declared, will quite naturally believe in the free movement of labor.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 3:49 · source · permalink
    18. JD Vance

      Vance argues worker replacement by foreign labor was the desired outcome of American elites, not an accident.

      “Being replaced by foreign workers, in other words, it was not an accident, my friends. It was the desired outcome of a generation of American elites.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 4:08 · source · permalink
    19. JD Vance

      Vance describes American workers being forced to train their foreign replacements before losing their jobs.

      “In other cases, American workers didn't just have their jobs destroyed, they got told they were being replaced by a foreign worker, and then they had to train that worker before they got replaced.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 4:41 · source · permalink
    20. JD Vance

      Vance says Kevin Flanagan had to train his foreign replacement to receive severance, then committed suicide.

      “And the business, the bank, they told him, you're only gonna get your severance package if you trained a foreign replacement to do your job instead. And it's a heartbreaking story because he did it.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 5:12 · source · permalink
    21. JD Vance

      Vance recounts Kevin Flanagan, a programmer told to train his foreign replacement to receive severance in 1987.

      “And the business, the bank, they told him, you're only gonna get your severance package if you trained a foreign replacement to do your job instead.”

      21 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 5:12 · source · permalink
    22. JD Vance

      Vance recalls a media anchor dismissing Venezuelan gangs taking over 'only one or two' apartment complexes in Aurora, Colorado.

      “And the anchor comes back and says to me, she says, well, they've only taken over one or two apartment complexes.”

      22 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:48 · source · permalink
    23. JD Vance

      Vance declares any foreign drug gang presence is unacceptable and justifies deportation with strong language.

      “a single apartment complex or a single home taken over by a foreign drug gang is one too many, which is why we gotta get those people the hell out of The United States Of America.”

      22 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 1:13 · source · permalink
    24. JD Vance

      Vance characterizes the old consensus as prioritizing corporate profits and foreign workers over citizens.

      “What we really needed, they told us, was just to juice the short term profits of a few big corporations. We needed to open that border and prioritize foreign workers over our own citizens.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:51 · source · permalink
    25. JD Vance

      Vance argues the establishment prioritized foreign workers and cheered corporate raiders slashing jobs.

      “We needed to open that border and prioritize foreign workers over our own citizens. They would cheer on the corporate raiders as they slashed headcount”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:58 · source · permalink
    26. JD Vance

      Vance accuses politicians of cheering corporate raiders who offshored jobs or hired illegal aliens.

      “They would cheer on the corporate raiders as they slashed headcount and shifted all those businesses either to foreign countries or brought in illegal aliens to employ.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 1:05 · source · permalink
    27. JD Vance

      Vance says the administration has deported thousands of violent criminals and fraudsters.

      “we've deported thousands of violent predators, criminals, fraudsters, and other people who are making it harder for law abiding citizens to live their lives.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:45 · source · permalink
    28. JD Vance

      Vance argues that millions of illegal aliens increased housing costs by taking homes from American citizens.

      “And when you give them houses that all go by right to American citizens, that's gonna increase the cost of housing for everybody else.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 1:15 · source · permalink
    29. JD Vance

      Vance claims rents are falling for the first time in a decade under Trump due to deportations.

      “Where housing doubled under the leadership of Joe Biden, rents are falling for the first time in a decade under the leadership of Donald Trump because we got people who shouldn't be here the hell out of our country.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 1:27 · source · permalink
    30. JD Vance

      Vance accuses Democrats of prioritizing one shooting over tens of thousands of Maine fentanyl deaths.

      “what I see from Democrats is people who are far more worried about a shooting involving an illegal alien than they are about the fact that tens of thousands of Mainers died from fentanyl overdoses by that poison brought into our community.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:05 · source · permalink
    31. JD Vance

      Vance accuses Democrats of prioritizing one shooting over tens of thousands of Maine fentanyl deaths.

      “what I see from Democrats is people who are far more worried about a shooting involving an illegal alien than they are about the fact that tens of thousands of Mainers died from fentanyl overdoses”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:05 · source · permalink
    32. JD Vance

      Vance tells Democrats to have perspective on the ICE shooting controversy.

      “my message to the Democrats who are so worried about that situation is to say, have a little bit of perspective.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:25 · source · permalink
    33. JD Vance

      Vance tells Democrats to have perspective, promises investigation of every shooting including ICE incident.

      “my message to the Democrats who are so worried about that situation is to say, have a little bit of perspective. We can absolutely investigate every shooting and we will,”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:25 · source · permalink
    34. JD Vance

      Vance commits to investigating shootings while prioritizing border security and stopping fentanyl.

      “We can absolutely investigate every shooting and we will, but we can also secure our border and ensure that that poison stops coming into our country.”

      24 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 2:31 · source · permalink
    35. “And did you know this is the craziest statistic of the entire last administration, that all of the net job creation under Joe Biden's leadership went to foreign born Americans, mostly illegal aliens.”

      25 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:09 · source · permalink
    36. JD Vance

      Vance claims all net job creation under Biden went to foreign-born Americans, mostly illegal aliens.

      “did you know this is the craziest statistic of the entire last administration, that all of the net job creation under Joe Biden's leadership went to foreign born Americans, mostly illegal aliens.”

      25 Aug 2026 · Forbes Breaking News · 0:09 · source · permalink
    1. Scott Bessent

      Bessent declares that illegal aliens will no longer collect taxpayer-funded benefits under Treasury enforcement.

      ““Under President Trump, the days of illegal aliens collecting taxpayer-funded benefits are over. The federal law is clear, and Treasury is enforcing it,””

      · Treasury press and remarks · 0:24 · source · permalink
    2. Scott Bessent

      Bessent argues taxpayers should not fund benefits for those legally barred from receiving them.

      ““American taxpayers should not be forced to foot the bill for benefits going to those who are barred by law from receiving them.”

      · Treasury press and remarks · 0:37 · source · permalink
    3. Scott Bessent

      Bessent says the regulations end abuse, protect tax system integrity, and prioritize Americans.

      “These proposed regulations end the abuse, protect the integrity of the tax system, and put Americans first.””

      · Treasury press and remarks · 0:48 · source · permalink
    4. Scott Bessent

      Bessent states the action prevents illegal and non-qualified aliens from receiving public benefits they are ineligible for.

      “This action cracks down on the abuse of taxpayer-funded refundable individual income tax credits and ensures that illegal aliens and other non-qualified aliens barred by federal law do not receive public benefits, which they are ineligible to receive.”

      · Treasury press and remarks · 1:44 · source · permalink
    5. Scott Bessent

      Bessent states that only U.S. citizens, nationals, and qualified aliens can receive federal public benefits under PRWORA.

      “Under PRWORA, only U.S. citizens, U.S. nationals, and qualified aliens are eligible to receive federal public benefits.”

      · Treasury press and remarks · 2:01 · source · permalink
    6. John Williams

      Williams expects uncertainty, tariffs, and reduced immigration to restrain spending and labor force growth.

      “But based on what the data tell us today, I expect uncertainty and tariffs to restrain spending and reduced immigration to slow labor force growth.”

      · NY Fed speeches · 9:26 · source · permalink
    7. John Williams

      Williams expects trade and immigration policies combined with uncertainty to weigh on growth.

      “But based on what the data tell us today, I expect the combined effects of trade and immigration policies and associated uncertainty to continue to weigh on growth.”

      · NY Fed speeches · 10:23 · source · permalink

Where they overlapsame programme, same subject

Every subject on the record · RSS